Forget Katy Perry’s Replacement! ‘American Idol’ Needs to End (2024)

Few reality shows have produced as many massive stars as American Idol. Created by Simon Robert Fuller and broadcasting on ABC, this series has amazed viewers for over two decades. Each season introduces a whole new batch of talented singers trying to win the grand prize and hopefully launch their careers into stardom. It has evolved many times over the years with rule changes and shifting judges introducing new styles of this classic format - to varying results. It's undeniable that after about its tenth season, American Idol began dropping in popularity. The show failed to elicit the fanfare and excitement of its first few seasons, plus no contestant in this newer era ever reached the heights of fame that many of its earlier ones did.

Recent years have seen the show be reinvigorated, though, and it's all due to one person: Katy Perry. This pop star joined Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie on the judges' panel, and while each man is an exceptional judge, the show was missing the quirky sense of fun this artist brings to every project. It was her fiery energy and witty humor that brought a sense of excitement back to this franchise, which is why so many fans were sad to hear that this latest season would be her last. She is leaving the panel, and people are wondering who will replace her. Though a much better plan would be for her leaving to signal the end of this legendary program. The worst thing that can happen for a series is overstaying its welcome, and with Katy Perry disrupting what has become a very lackluster time for the franchise, it may be time for American Idol to leave with her and end on a (rare) high note.

American Idol

Reality-TV

Music

See Also

Why has the public turned its back on Katy Perry? A chronicle of the pop star’s downfall

Game Show

Documentary

Twelve American finalists (six men and six women) compete in a singing contest.

Release Date

June 11, 2002

Creator

Simon Fuller

Cast

Carrie Underwood , Fantasia , Jennifer Hudson , Clay Aiken , Chris Daughtry

Seasons

22

'American Idol' Has Seen Better Days

It's undeniable that so many singing competition shows would never have been possible without American Idol. When this reality series premiered in 2002, it revolutionized how viewers watched TV; reality competition shows had existed before, but never had they been such a showcase of talent, with skillful editing and charming contestants making audiences really care about these singers and their fights to follow their dreams. It's a program that created some of the biggest names in music, with winners like Kelly Clarkson and even non-winners like Jennifer Hudson using the series to launch award-winning careers that still haven't stopped to this day. It had a high viewership, amazing stars, and one of the best judging panels out there - unfortunately, that level of fame wasn't meant to last.

There are many theories over what led to American Idol's steady decline in popularity. Some people cite the original judges' Paula Abdul, Simon Cowell, and Randy Jackson - the trio who gave this series so much of its uniquely enjoyable appeal. Leaving the franchise marked the end of what made it so great. Others think that American Idol's inspiring nature was what eventually led to its downfall, with ratings competitors like The Voice and America's Got Talent imitating the original show dynamics and drawing some of its long-lasting audience away. No matter what combination of circ*mstances did it, most of the last decade has seen the series experience many bouts of low viewership and a distinct lack of excitement from people online. Its premise of bringing together large groups of singers and having them compete has grown stale, especially since it's been so many years since any of the winners they spend an entire season hyping up have become a household name. American Idol was on a downward spiral, being critiqued for its repetitive nature and lack of cultural relevance, which is right when Katy Perry showed up.

Katy Perry Was What 'American Idol' Needed

The pop star known for hits like "Firework" and "I Kissed a Girl" joined American Idol's judging panel in the show's 16th season, completing the trio of Karl Urban and Lionel Richie and bringing a much-needed dose of her signature energy into the show. The past few seasons have seen an uptick in conversations around the show, and most of that is due to Perry; of course, the singers competing are as talented as ever, but it was her wacky antics that had most people tuning in to watch and sharing clips of each episode after it was done airing. Whether she was giving audiences an in-depth lesson on the term "Wig" or falling out of her chair dressed as a little mermaid, her wackiness, paired with an immense level of vocal excellence and industry knowledge, made her exactly what the series needed to regain some of its lost popularity. She's the reason that it got back some of that televised star power, and that's why her leaving is the reason it should end.

There are countless examples of shows that began fantastic and went on for too long, so desperate to recapture that initial greatness that eventually they become a hard-to-watch imitation of something that was too distinct to ever replicate. These often end in a quiet cancelation. Audiences are tired of the series and its lack of excitement, spelling the end for its TV lifespan. As legendary as American Idol is, it seems to be approaching this terrifying point. Katy Perry's inclusion may have given it a much-needed boost, but that doesn't discount the many stunted installments before that or the clear decline in social awareness of what's happening in the series and who its winners are. By ending now, it'd be going out as a current success, Perry granting it a few more seasons of being one of the biggest shows in America before it settles back into being a typical competition show that used to be the best there was. It's unfortunate because of how integral this series has been to reality television as a whole, but unless it wants to face a disappointing end with little fanfare, American Idol should end now while it's still remembered fondly.

'American Idol' Should Go Out With A Bang!

When it comes to historical reality series, American Idol deserves so much praise for all it's been able to accomplish since premiering in 2002. In so many ways, this program jump started the genre, introducing American viewers to how utterly iconic singing competitions can be and creating many of the elements and styles that define reality television today. It was essential in creating the modern TV landscape, and that's exactly why it should end with Katy Perry leaving the judging panel. She wasn't the only reason the past few seasons were good, but she is definitely one of the main things that made the latest portion of the show not only improve in quality but actually get back some of the cultural relevance it's been struggling to reclaim. There would be nothing worse than for this historic series to fall back into being only a fraction of the immensely famous competition it once was, and if it ended right now, it'd be going out at a comparable level to how well-known it was back in the beginning. As sad as it is to say, American Idol's best days seem to be behind it, and this pop princess' departure could be the last time this show could choose to end while still being popular - instead of a sad cancelation that could be approaching fast.

American Idol is Available to Stream on Hulu in the U.S.

WATCH ON HULU